It was a pretty good quarter for stocks, with the riskier small-cap and emerging market stocks leading the way. REIT’s gave back some of their robust returns of prior periods. The year-to-date numbers for stocks are solid as well.
The riskier markets have done better this quarter, which is consistent with an increased appetite for risk. One concern is that much of the recent returns can be explained by the need to reach for risk to expect any sort of return. This can lead to a general mispricing of risk. Consequently, these excess returns are apt to be temporary.
The grey bar showing international markets in the above chart, except for the most recent quarter, hasn’t reached the heights of other market returns. It shows that this market has not kept pace with others over these periods. However, be careful as it says nothing about future returns from international markets.
The accompanying yield curves chart shows the yield to maturity of Treasury securities of various maturities. Note the little change over the September quarter, which is consistent with a more or less flat bond market. Yields for longer maturities have fallen since the beginning of the year, which reflects the relative attractiveness of U.S. Treasury securities in a world of negative interest rates.
Credit spreads (the difference between yields on corporate bonds versus comparable Treasury securities) have declined over the past quarter resulting in positive returns from investment grade corporate and especially high yield bonds. These declines are consistent with our theme of an increased appetite for risk.
The Value of Capital
I am usually skeptical of suggestions that we are entering a “new normal.” Yet, a case might be made that this time it’s different. The axiom that capital has value can be questioned – Central Banks can’t seem to give it away! Interest rates are the “price” of capital – it’s what’s paid to use capital. Interest rates near zero and, in some places, negative provides an indication of the value of capital today.
Central Banks worldwide, including the Fed, are not shy at providing capital at little or no cost. Banks are holding massive amounts of reserves; there is little appetite for rebuilding infrastructure and many corporations are finding the best use of capital is to buy back stock. Furthermore, in developed economies, human capital – not physical capital – is more of a driver of economic growth today. Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, Google and Amazon are relatively new names among today’s largest corporations, each of which is engaged in managing human capital primarily. This shift away from physical capital helps to explain the decline in demand and is consistent with a lower price of capital into the future. Perhaps a new normal.
This apparent reduced value for capital has implications for investors. First, is this really a new normal or is it temporary? Second, what is the impact on the price of risk going forward? Third, can we earn the returns of the past by judiciously managing risk, or will we have to accept reduced expected returns going forward? Fourth, are markets signaling deflation ahead?
As I said, I am generally skeptical of paradigm shifts and suggestions of a new normal. We have to deal with a lot of random behavior, and capital markets can be out of whack for extended periods. The current distortion could simply be the result of Central Banks acting alone without changes in fiscal policy to produce economic growth. Consequently, we must be careful about shifting our ideas about how the world works in response to what could turn out to be temporary aberrations.
Other articles filed under Investing
April 21, 2017
On March 15, 2017, the Federal Reserve increased interest rates for just the third time since the financial crisis in 2008-2009. Investment theory tells us when interest rates rise, bond prices fall, so rising interest rates are bad for bond...
April 17, 2017
The stock market crash of 2008-2009 is a very recent memory for many investors who still bear the scars from the experience. At Rockbridge, we also have prospective clients who walk into our offices saying that they haven’t recovered yet...
March 23, 2017
Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association, better known as TIAA was founded almost 100 years ago (1918). TIAA provides retirement plan solutions for a majority of the higher education institutions in the United States. One type of investment, called the TIAA...
January 23, 2017
Stock Markets While markets were down early in the quarter, most, but not all, have bounced back since the Election with small company stocks and value stocks leading the way. Stocks traded in international markets and emerging markets have not...
January 17, 2017
There is much talk and concern about increasing interest rates, which will not be good for bond performance. Below are responses to some of the specific questions we have received from clients. Q: Why have interest rates increased since the...